Halloween candy is dandy - even when it's fish, guts and onions
October 25th, 2013
09:00 AM ET
Share this on:

Kate Krader (@kkrader on Twitter) is Food & Wine's restaurant editor. When she tells us where to find our culinary heart's desire, we listen up.

I have a high tolerance for Halloween candy. My preference is for mini bars that have a good ratio of chocolate to caramel to something salty and crunchy (I’m looking longingly at you, Take 5 bars!). I can, however, also blow through non-chocolate items like candy corn, Skittles and even Nerds.

But there are some candies out there that are so ridiculously gross and silly that I won’t have anything to do with them. You can say, “They’re just regular candy dressed up as something silly.” And you’d be right. Still, I’m going to leave all the gummy internal organs and pickle gumballs for someone else.

Meatball Bubble Gum
These candies look exactly like beige-brown meatballs, but they’re actually regular bubblegum-flavored. And probably good for a practical joke at family dinner if you have any leftover after Halloween.

Onion Ring Mints
Mints are the one candy on my Avoid on Halloween list. These mints, which successfully give you onion breath, are at the top of that list. You get 100 fried onion flavored mints in each tin for $3.

Gummy Internal Organs
A 38-piece bag of this candy includes gummy brains, kidneys, hearts and intestinal tracts. All are individually wrapped, and come in assorted fruit flavors.

Gravy Candy
Hard candies are also pretty much a Halloween nonstarter for most people (and me). For better or worse, these red-and-white striped hard candies are gravy-flavored, and might be handy at Thanksgiving.

Fish Head Lollipop
These lollipops look exactly, and I mean exactly, like the severed head of a small fish, complete with bloody red insides. The flavor is sour lemon, and they’re $6 each.

Giant Gummy Worm
Here’s a gross candy that’s also big enough to put you into sugar shock: A 3-pound, 2-foot long gummy worm, available in Blue Raspberry–Red Cherry flavor, or Orange & Yellow. (Perhaps that’s orange & lemon flavor? I don’t think I’ll ever know.) They’re $30 each.

Harry Potter Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans
I’m sure you’ve seen these before. I’ll just remind you that among the 20 flavors you might get in each box you could find Booger, Dirt, Earthworm, Earwax, Rotten Egg, Sausage and Vomit.

Pickle Gumballs
As you might expect, these are dill pickle–flavored gumballs, tart and slightly sweet. They arrive in a tin that features a picture of a pickle blowing a bubble.

Chocolate Zombie Fingers
Arrayed on a Styrofoam meat tray are these green-colored chocolate fingers with gushing fruit candies inside so you get the proper bloody effect.

Spider in Candy Boxes
The boxes look like they hold standard Halloween candy: Mighty Mints, Spots Gummy Dots and Rocks, the boxes say. But inside there’s a spider instead of candy. At least it’s made of plastic.

More from Food & Wine:
Ultimate Candy Guide
Spooky Halloween Desserts
Best Chocolate in the U.S.
America’s Greatest Chocolate Chip Cookies
Homemade Chocolate Candies

Halloween party tricks and boozy treats
Homemade peanut butter cups
The kid who couldn't trick-or-treat

© 2011 American Express Publishing Corporation. All rights reserved.

Posted by:
Filed under: Candy • Content Partner • Food and Wine • Halloween • Halloween • Holiday

soundoff (One Response)
  1. Thinking things through

    I'd love to find a giant gummy rat. Not to eat, mind you, but just to have on display at this time of year.

    October 27, 2013 at 6:39 pm |
| Part of